3.4.5 Receptacle and Process Loads

Receptacle and process loads contribute to heat gains in spaces and directly use energy.

Receptacle Power (except multi-family residential)

Applicability

All building projects except multi-family residential

Definition

Receptacle power includes computers, monitors, printers, copiers, vending machines, residential size refrigerators, personal space heaters and other equipment loads normally served through conventional electrical receptacles. Small servers are included with receptacle power, but large data centers are generally modeled separately. As a rule-of-thumb, if the servers are in a room with a dedicated HVAC system, they should be modeled separately. Receptacle power does not include task lighting, equipment used for HVAC purposes, open or closed refrigeration cases, walk-in freezers and refrigerators, elevators, and commercial cooking equipment. These loads should be modeled separately.  See Sections 6.4.6, 6.4.7 and 6.4.8 for guidelines and requirements on how to model these process loads. Receptacle power is specified at the space level and is modified by the receptacle schedule. Values in the default receptacle schedules for each hour approach but do not exceed 1.0 (see Appendix C).

Receptacle power is generally considered an unregulated load and is treated as a neutral dependent input; no credit has been offered for savings. Identical assumptions are made for both the baseline building and the proposed design.

Offering credit for receptacle loads is difficult due to their temporal nature and because information is not always available on what equipment will go into the building at the time the plans are being reviewed. Tenants also have the ability to plug and unplug devices or switch them out for different equipment, adding to the difficulty of assigning credit for promised energy efficiency.

COMNET provides a procedure for crediting plug load reductions for building owners and/or managers who are willing to make a long-term commitment to purchase ENERGY STAR equipment. 

Units

Total power (W) for the space or power density (W/ft²)

Input Restrictions

Receptacle loads in the proposed design may be calculated in one of three ways:. The first method is neutral independent, the second method is neutral dependent, and the third method treats equipment that result in receptacle loads as an asset and credit may be taken for power reductions from surveyed devices. The three methods are as follows:

1. The COMNET recommended defaults from Appendix B may be used, in which case the same values are used for the baseline building and there is no credit for reductions in the proposed design.

2. If detailed information is known, the receptacle power can be calculated using Equations 3.4.5-1 and 3.4.5-2. In this instance, the energy analyst must be able to estimate the number of personal computers, the number of printers and the number of other equipment in the space, as listed in Table 3.4.5-1. If detailed information is not available, then Method 1 must be used. With Method 2, “Baseline” power from Table 3.4.5-1 shall be used for both the baseline building and the proposed design.

3. If detailed information is known and the owner/property manager is willing to make a long term commitment to require ENERGY STAR equipment throughout the building, then Method 3 may be used. Method 3 is the same as Method 2, except that the proposed design may use reduced equipment power for surveyed devices from Table 3.4.5-1 based on the ‘Length of ENERGY STAR Commitment’.

Baseline Rules

With Methods 1 and 2, the receptacle power in the baseline building shall be the same as the proposed design. With Method 3, the ‘Baseline’ equipment values from Table 3.4.5-1 are used with Equations 6.4.5-1 and 6.4.5-2 to determine the equipment power for the baseline building.

Requirements for Long Term Commitment

One of the largest hurdles is establishing accountability for receptacle load reductions; savings must be verified and credible. A commitment to future good behavior must  be documented appropriately, either in leasing language, within corporate or governmental resolutions, or in tenant manuals to ensure that ENERGY STAR equipment will be used not only initially but also for future replacements. The inability to verify long term commitments is one of the obstacles to offering credits for plug load reductions, since the equipment that makes up receptacle loads is short lived and generally replaced within a 3-5 year timeframe.

Equations for Estimating Receptacle Loads (Methods 2 and 3)

This procedure provides a means for more accurately estimating plug loads (Method 2) and for taking credit for energy reductions when the owner is willing to initially install all ENERGY STAR equipment and make a long term commitment to purchase ENERGY STAR equipment for replacements and additions (Method 3). COMNET Methods 2 and 3 are based on procedures developed by NREL1 which estimate receptacle and process power density based on a count of computers, printers and other equipment in the space (surveyed equipment). The procedure is shown in Equations 3.4.5-1 and 3.4.5-2.

(Equation 3.4.5-1)

$$P=\left ( C_{sd}\cdot PD_{sd}+PD{_{misc}} \right )$$

where

P           is the estimated power density for the space in W/ft².

PDsd     is an estimate of receptacle power from personal computers, monitors, servers, printers and other “surveyed devices” determined from Equation (3.4.5-2). Units are W/ft².

PDmisc  is an estimate from Appendix B of miscellaneous receptacle power for equipment not specifically accounted for in PDsd. This value depends on the occupancy of the space.

Csd,      is an adjustment coefficient from Appendix B based on the occupancy of the space. This coefficient along with PDmisc accounts for equipment that is not included among the “surveyed devices”. Csd scales the equipment power of “surveyed devices”, while PDmisc is a constant.

d           is a diversity factor from Appendix B based on the occupancy of the space.

(Equation 3.4.5-2)

$$PD_{sd}=\frac{\begin{bmatrix}
N_{PCdt}\cdot P_{PCdt}+N_{PCnb}\cdot P_{PCnb}+N_{Mon}\cdot P_{Mon}+N_{Svr}\cdot P_{Svr}+\\ 
N_{POS}\cdot P_{POS}+N_{PRNTlas}\cdot P_{PRNTlas}+N_{PRNTink}\cdot P_{PRNTink}+\\N_{Copy}\cdot P_{Copy}+N_{Fax}\cdot P_{Fax}+N_{Refrig}\cdot P_{Refrog}+N_{Vend}\cdot P_{Vend}
\\ 
\end{bmatrix}}{Area}$$

where

Nxx        is the number of devices in the proposed design for the “xx” surveyed device in question. See Table 3.4.5-1 for a list of surveyed devices to be included.

Pxx        is the nominal mean power from Table 3.4.5-1 for the “xx” surveyed device in question.

Area      is the area of the space in ft².

Credit is limited to equipment listed in Table 3.4.5-1 where the ENERGY STAR program applies, including PCs, monitors, copiers, laser and inkjet printers, vending machines, and refrigerators. No credit is offered for equipment not listed in Table 3.4.5-1.

1. Griffith, B, et. al., Methodology for Modeling Building Energy Performance across the Commercial Sector, Technical Report, (NREL/TP-550-41956, March 2008, Appendix C, Section C.14. Note that elevators and escalators have been removed from the NREL equation, since they are treated separately.

Table 3.4.5-1: Nominal Mean Power for Surveyed Devices

Source: See 150928 Plug Loads Calcs TSD.pdf

Subscript

Description

Baseline

Length of ENERGY STAR Commitment

5 y

10 y

15 y

20 y

30 y

PCdt

Desktop Computer

65

58

52

47

43

37

PCnb

Notebook Computer

25

22

20

18

17

15

Mon

Monitor

30

28

26

25

24

23

Svr

Server

524

524

524

524

524

524

POS

Point of Sale Device

48

48

48

48

48

48

PRNTlas

Printer Laser

110

102

96

91

87

81

PRNTink

Printer Inkjet

25

22

19

17

16

13

Copy

Copy Machine

372

365

360

356

352

347

Fax

Fax Machine

55

51

47

44

42

39

Refrig

Residential Refrigerator

350

332

317

304

294

280

Vend

Vending Machine

400

363

333

308

288

259

Receptacle Power Multi-Family Residential

Applicability

Multi-family residential building projects

Definition

For multi-family projects, receptacle power includes the refrigerator, cooking equipment, clothes washer, clothes dryer and other major appliances. Receptacle power is specified at the space level and is modified by the receptacle schedule. Values in the default receptacle schedules for each hour approach but do not exceed 1.0 (see Appendix C).

Much receptacle power in residences is considered unregulated load and is modeled as a neutral independent input; no credit is offered for savings. Identical assumptions are made for both the baseline building and the proposed design. However for refrigerators and clothes washers, the modeling assumptions for the proposed building can differ from the baseline building when ENERGY STAR complying equipment is used in the proposed design. 

Units

Total power (W) for the space or power density (W/ft²)

Input Restrictions

Receptacle loads in the proposed design shall be calculated on the basis of: the number of dwelling units, the number of bedrooms, the floor area, and the use of ENERGY STAR appliances. Credit for ENERGY STAR appliances applies only to refrigerators and clothes washers. Other equipment energy use is neutral independent. Lobbies, corridors and other common spaces shall determine plug and process electrical loads using the general procedure for nonresidential buildings.  

Baseline Rules

The receptacle power in the baseline building shall be determined using the same method (see below) as the proposed design, but conventional equipment shall be assumed for the refrigerator and clothes washer. 

Procedure for Estimating Receptacle Power

Receptacle loads in the proposed design may be calculated in one of two ways:1 . The first simplified method may be used when each dwelling unit has its own clothes washer and dryer and all of the dwelling units use either electricity or gas for cooking and clothes drying. The second method is more flexible and must be used when some dwelling units have in-unit washers and dryers and some do not, or when some of the dwelling units use gas while others use electricity. The two methods are as follows:

Method One

The annual electric energy for dwelling units in the multi-family building is given by equation 3.4.5-3 below:

(Equation 3.4.5-3)

$$ kWh_{total} = NmbrDU \cdot a + NmbrBR \cdot b + FlrArea \cdot c $$

where

kWhtotal      the total annual electrical receptacle energy for the multi-family building (kWh/y)

NmbrDU     number of dwelling units in the multi-family building

NmbrBR     number of bedrooms in the multi-family building (efficiency apartments count as one)

FlrArea       finished floor area for all dwelling units. 

a, b, and c  coefficients taken from Table 3.4.5-2

Table 3.4.5-2: Annual Residential Energy Use - Method One

Note: Use values in parenthesis when all the dwelling units have ENERGY STAR refrigerators and clothes washers.

  a b c
All electric 1632 (1502) 139 1.05
Gas cooking/drying 648 (518) 12.7 1.05

Once kWhtotal is determined, it is converted to power by dividing by the number of full-time equivalent hours used in the receptacle schedule and by adjusting units. This step is shown in equation 3.4.5-4. . 

(Equation 3.4.5-4)

$$Power (W/ft2) = \frac{kWh_{total} \cdot 1,000}{FTEhours}$$

where

FTEhours   full-time equivalent hours used in the receptacle schedule. The default value from Appendix C is 5,840 hours (hours)

Method Two

Method Two can be used under any conditions, but is required when some or all of the clothes washers and/or dryers are located in common areas or when some of the dwelling units have gas for cooking and or drying clothes while other units use electricity. 

The annual electricity use is given in equations 3.4.5-5 through 3.4.5-10:

(Equation 3.4.5-5)

$$kWh_{total}=kWh_{ref}+kWh_{cths}+kWh_{cook}+kWh_{dry}+kWh_{misc}$$

(Equation 3.4.5-6)

$$kWh_{ref} = NmbrDU_{E*} \cdot 423 + NmbrDU_{conv} \cdot 529$$

(Equation 3.4.5-7)

$$\begin{align} kWh_{du,cths} = & NmbrCW_{du,E*} \cdot 57 + NmbrCW_{du,conv} \cdot 81 + \\ & NmbrCW_{com,E*} \cdot 138 + NmbrCW_{com,conv} \cdot 196 \end{align} $$

(Equation 3.4.5-8)

$$kWh_{cook} = NmbrDU_{EC} \cdot 604$$

(Equation 3.4.5-9)

$$\begin{align} kWh_{dry} = & NmbrDry_{du,elec} \cdot 418 + NmbrBR_{du,elec} \cdot 139 + \\ & NmbrDry_{com,elec} \cdot 1013 + NmbrBR_{com,elec} \cdot 337 + \\ & NmbrDry_{du,gas} \cdot 38 + NmbrBR_{du,gas} \cdot 12.7+ \\ & NmbrDry_{com,gas} \cdot 92.1 + NmbrBR_{com,gas} \cdot 30.8 \end{align}$$

(Equation 3.4.5-10)

$$kWh_{misc} = FlrArea \cdot 1.05$$

where

kWhtotal      the total annual electrical receptacle energy for the multi-family building (kWh/y)

kWhref        the annual refrigerator energy for the multi-family building (kWh/y)

kWhcths      the annual clothes washer energy for the multi-family building (kWh/y)

kWhcook     the annual cooking energy for the multi-family building (kWh/y)

kWhdry       the annual clothes dryer energy for the multi-family building (kWh/y)

kWhmisc      the annual miscellaneous energy for the multi-family building (kWh/y)

NmbrDUE*   number of dwelling units with ENERGY STAR refrigerator

NmbrDUconv   number of dwelling units with conventional refrigerator

NmbrCWdu,E*   number of ENERGY STAR clothes washers located in dwelling units

NmbrCWcom,E*  number of ENERGY STAR clothes washers located in common areas

NmbrCWdu,conv  number of conventional clothes washers located in dwelling units

NmbrCWcom,conv   number of conventional clothes washers located in common areas

NmbrDUEC  number of dwelling units with electric cooking

NmbrDrydu,elec   number of electric clothes dryers in dwelling units

NmbrDrycom,elec   number of electric clothes dryers in common areas

NmbrDrydu,gas   number of gas clothes dryers in dwelling units

NmbrDrydu,gas   number of gas dryers in common areas

NmbrBRdu,elec   number of bedrooms served by electric clothes dryers in dwelling units

NmbrBRcom,elec   number of bedrooms served by electric clothes dryers in common areas

NmbrBRdu,gas   number of bedrooms served by gas clothes dryers in dwelling units

NmbrBRcom,gas   number of bedrooms served by gas clothes dryers in common areas

FlrArea     finished floor area for all dwelling units. 

Once kWhtotal is calculated, it is converted to power by dividing by the full-time equivalent (FTE) hours in the schedule of operation and adjusting the units. See equation 3.4.5-4.  

Table 3.4.5-3: Annual Residential Energy Use 

 

Annual Energy Use

Load Fraction

 

Per Unit

Per BR

Per Area

Sensible

Latent

Electricity in Dwelling Unit (kWh/y)

       

Refrigeratora

529 (423)

0

0

1.00

0.00

Clothes washera

81 (57)

0

0

0.60

0.15

Cooking

604

0

0

0.40

0.30

Clothes dryer (electric)

418

139

0

0.15

0.05

Clothes dryer (gas)

38.0

12.7

0

1.00

0.00

Miscellaneous

0

0

1.05

0.90

0.10

           

Electricity in Common Space Laundry (kWh/y)

     

Clothes washer

196 (138)

0

0

0.60

0.15

Clothes dryer (electric)

1013

337

0

0.15

0.05

Clothes dryer (gas)

92.1

30.8

0

1.00

0.00

           

Gas in Dwelling Unit (therms/y)b

       

Cooking

45

0

0

0.40

0.30

Clothes dryer

26.5

8.8

0

0.10

0.05

           

Gas in Common Laundry Space (therms/y)b

 

 

 

Clothes dryer

64.2

21.3

0

0.10

0.05

a. Values in parenthesis are to be used for ENERGY STAR equipment in the proposed design

b. Gas in residential dwelling units is addressed in section 3.4.8. 

 

Receptacle Schedule

Applicability

All projects

Definition

Schedule for receptacle power loads used to adjust the intensity on an hourly basis to reflect time-dependent patterns of usage.

Units

Data structure: schedule, fraction

Input Restrictions

The default schedule is taken from Tables 1 through 11 of Appendix C.

Baseline Rules

Schedules for the baseline building shall be identical to the proposed design.

  • 1Both methods are developed from information contained in the ENERGY STAR Multi-Family Highrise Simulation Guidelines, Version 1.0, Revision 03, January 2015, pages 23-35.
90.1-2019

Receptacle loads contribute to heat gains in spaces and directly use energy.

Receptacle Power

Applicability

All building projects

Definition

Receptacle power is power for typical general service loads in the building. Receptacle power includes equipment loads normally served through electrical receptacles, such as office equipment and printers, but does not include either task lighting or equipment used for HVAC purposes. Receptacle power values are generally higher than the largest hourly receptacle load that is actually modeled because the receptacle power values are modified by the receptacle schedule, which approaches but does not exceed 1.0.

The equipment plugged into receptacles are considered unregulated loads, hence no credit is given for improvements to the efficiency of that equipment, when the PRM is used for compliance with the standard. However, when quantifying performance that exceeds the requirements of Standard 90.1, credit for reductions in receptacle power may be granted as described below under Baseline Building

Control of those receptacles is regulated by Standard 90.1 and that is discussed in descriptor Automatic  Receptacle Control.

Units

Total power (W) for the space or power density (W/ft²)

Software shall also use the prescribed values below to specify the latent heat gain fraction and the radiative/convective heat gain split.

For software that specifies the fraction of the heat gain that is lost from the space, this fraction shall be prescribed at 0 unless the equipment is located under an exhaust hood.

Input Restrictions

Receptacle and process loads, such as those for office and other equipment, shall be estimated based on the building type or space type category. These loads shall be included in simulations of the building and shall be included when calculating the baseline building performance and proposed building performance.

For Standard 90.1-2019, receptacle loads in the proposed design may be calculated in one of two ways:

  • As designed or assumed by the design team for loads calculation. Great care must be used in the application of space design receptacle loads from HVAC or electrical designers as these may not include appropriate diversity to represent annual operation.
  • Standard 90.1-2019 recommended defaults may be used, in which case the same values must be used for the baseline building and there is no credit for reductions.

Baseline Building

The receptacle power and process loads in the baseline building shall be the same as the proposed design.

However, when quantifying performance that exceeds the requirements of Standard 90.1 (but not when using the Performance Rating as an alternative path for minimum standard compliance ), with approval of the rating authority, variations of the power requirements, schedules, or control sequences of the equipment modeled in the baseline building from those in the proposed design shall be allowed by the rating authority based upon documentation that the equipment installed in the proposed design represents a significant verifiable departure from documented conventional practice. In such bases, the baseline shall be determined based on prescriptive requirements in Standard 90.1-2019. When no such prescriptive requirements exisit, it shall be equal to requirements of other efficiency or equipment codes or standards applicable to the design of the building systems and equipment.

The burden of this documentation is to demonstrate that accepted conventional practice would result in baseline building equipment different from that installed in the proposed design. If baseline building plug loads differ from the proposed building, this input must be flagged and instructions given to provide the proper documentation.

 

Receptacle Heat Gain Fraction

Applicability

All projects

Definition

The electrical input to the equipment ultimately appears as heat that contributes to zone loads. This heat can be divided into four different fractions. These are given by the input fields:

  • Fraction Latent: This field is a decimal number between 0.0 and 1.0 and is used to characterize the amount of latent heat given off by electric equipment in a zone. The number specified in this field will be multiplied by the total energy consumed by electric equipment to give the amount of latent energy produced by the electric equipment. This energy affects the moisture balance within the zone.
  • Fraction Radiant: This field is a decimal number between 0.0 and 1.0 and is used to characterize the amount of long-wave radiant heat being given off by electric equipment in a zone. The number specified in this field will be multiplied by the total energy consumed by electric equipment to give the amount of long wavelength radiation gain from electric equipment in a zone.
  • Fraction Lost: This field is a decimal number between 0.0 and 1.0 and is used to characterize the amount of “lost” heat being given off by electric equipment in a zone. The number specified in this field will be multiplied by the total energy consumed by electric equipment to give the amount of heat that is “lost” and does not impact the zone energy balances. This might correspond to electrical energy converted to mechanical work or heat that is vented to the atmosphere.
  • Fraction Convected: This field is a decimal number between 0.0 and 1.0 and is used to characterize the fraction of the heat from electric equipment convected to the zone air.

The sum of all 4 of these fractions should be 1.

Units

Data structure: fraction

Input Restrictions

As designed. If not specified by the user, default values for receptacle power heat gain fractions will be used.

Radiative = 0.20, Latent = 0.00, Convective = 0.80, Lost =0.00

Baseline Building

Same as proposed

 

Receptacle Schedule

Applicability

All projects

Definition

Schedule for receptacle power loads used to adjust the intensity hourly to reflect time-dependent patterns of usage. These schedules are assumed to reflect the mandatory automatic receptacle control requirements.

Units

Data structure: schedule, fraction

Input Restrictions

Actual schedules shall be used when known. Default schedules documented in COMNET Appendix C (COMNET 2017) can be used when design schedules are not available.

Baseline Building

Schedules for the baseline building shall be identical to those for the proposed design except when-

  • Receptacle controls are installed in spaces not required by Standard 90.1-2019 Section 8.4.2. In this case the schedule can differ between baseline and proposed and the receptacle schedule for the proposed building can be modified as explained in the descriptor ‘Automatic Receptacle Control’.Or, when quantifying performance that exceeds the requirements of Standard 90.1 (but not when using the Performance Rating as an alternative path for minimum standard compliance ),with approval of the rating authority, variations of the power requirements, schedules, or control sequences of the equipment modeled in the baseline building from those in the proposed design shall be allowed based upon documentation that the equipment installed in the proposed design represents a significant verifiable departure from documented conventional practice. The burden of this documentation is to demonstrate that accepted conventional practice would result in baseline building equipment different from that installed in the proposed design. If baseline building plug loads differ from the proposed building, this input must be flagged and instructions given to provide the proper documentation.

 

Computer Room Equipment Schedule

Applicability

All projects with computer rooms

Definition

Schedule for computer room equipment loads used to adjust the intensity hourly to reflect time-dependent patterns of usage. Standard 90.1-2019 requires the use of a randomized schedule for computer rooms. The randomized computer room equipment schedule is intended to capture part load system performance in the proposed and base case models. While it is not realistic to have computer room loads vary drastically month to month, it is common for loads to vary gradually over months or years. The schedule shown here captures this effect in a single annual simulation. It also allows the various load conditions to be simulated under the various weather conditions.

Units

Data structure: schedule, fraction

Input Restrictions

Computer room equipment schedules shall be modeled as a constant fraction of the peak design load per the following monthly schedule:

Month 1, 5, 9—25%

Month 2, 6, 10—50%

Month 3, 7, 11—75%

Month 4, 8, 12—100%

Baseline Building

Same as proposed

 

Automatic Receptacle Control

Applicability

All projects

Definition

Automatic receptacle controls include devices that control receptacles based on time of day, occupancy sensors or a central control signal based on occupancy as required by Standard 90.1-2019, Section 8.4.2 requires that 50% of all applicable receptacle and 25% of applicable branch circuit feeders to be controlled using automatic receptacle controls which function on either:

a. A scheduled basis using a time-of-day operated control device that turns receptacles off at specific programmed times. This shall be provided for controlled areas of no more than 5000 ft2 and not more than one floor (the occupant shall be able to manually override the control device for up to two hours);

b. An occupant sensor that shall turn receptacles off within 20 minutes of all occupants leaving a space; or

c. An automated signal from another control or alarm system that shall turn receptacles off within 20 minutes after determining that the area is unoccupied.

All controlled receptacles should be uniformly distributed throughout the space.

Plug-in controls devices cannot be used to comply with these requirements

Exceptions to this requirement include:

a. Receptacles specifically designated for equipment requiring continuous operation (24/day, 365 days/year).

b. Spaces where an automatic control would endanger the safety or security of the room or building occupants.

Units

No units

Input Restrictions

As designed. For each space in the proposed building indicate which receptacle control strategies from the list above are included and the percentage of receptacles that are controlled. .

When receptacle controls are installed in spaces not required by Standard 90.1-2019 Section 8.4.2, credit for receptacle controls in the proposed design can be taken by decreasing the receptacle schedule in the proposed building design according to the following.

RPC RC x 10%

Hence, the receptacle schedule for each hour for the proposed building =

              EPSpro = EPSbas x (1- RPC)

Where:

RPC     = Receptacle power credit

RC       = Percentage of receptacles controlled according to one of the methods described above.

EPSbas  = Baseline equipment power hourly schedule (fraction)

EPSpro  = Proposed equipment power hourly schedule (fraction)

Baseline Building

Same as proposed before the automatic receptacle control credit is applied

90.1-2022

Commercial refrigeration equipment includes the following:

  • Walk-in refrigerators
  • Walk-in freezers
  • Refrigerated casework

Walk-in refrigerators and freezers typically have remote condensers. Some refrigerated casework has remote condensers, while some has a self-contained condenser built into the unit. Refrigerated casework with built-in condensers rejects heat directly to the space while remote condensers reject heat in the remote location, typically on the roof or behind the building.

Refrigerated casework can be further classified by the purpose, the type of doors and, when there are no doors, the configuration: horizontal, vertical, or semi-vertical. DOE has developed standards for refrigerated casework. Table 15 shows these classifications along with the standard level of performance, expressed in kWh/d, which depends on the class of equipment, the total display area, and the volume of the casework. Table 16 shows the performance requirements for walk-in refrigerators and freezers.

Table 15. Standard 90.1 Section G3.2 Performance Rating Method for Commercial Refrigerators and Freezers

Equipment Type

 Application

Energy Use Limits
kWh/day

 Test Procedure

Refrigerator with solid doors

Holding temperature

0.125 × V + 2.76

AHRI 1200

Refrigerator with transparent doors

0.172 × V + 4.77

Freezers with solid doors

0.398 × V + 2.28

Freezers with transparent doors

0.94 × V + 5.10

Refrigerators/freezers with solid doors

0.12 × V + 4.77

Commercial refrigerators

Pulldown

0.181 × V + 5.01

Note: V is the chiller or frozen compartment volume (ft3) as defined in Association of Home Appliance Manufacturers Standard HRF-1.

Table 16. Standard 90.1 Section G3.2 Performance Rating Method for Commercial Casework

Equipment Class(a)

Family Code

Operating Mode

Rating Temperature

Energy Use Limits, (b),(c)
kWh/day

Test Procedure

VOP.RC.M

Vertical open

Remote condensing

Medium temperature

1.01 × TDA + 4.07

AHRI 1200

SVO.RC.M

Semivertical open

Remote condensing

Medium temperature

1.01 × TDA + 3.18

HZO.RC.M

Horizontal open

Remote condensing

Medium temperature

0.51 × TDA + 2.88

VOP.RC.L

Vertical open

Remote condensing

Low temperature

2.84 × TDA + 6.85

HZO.RC.L

Horizontal open

Remote condensing

Low temperature

0.68 × TDA + 6.88

VCT.RC.M

Vertical transparent door

Remote condensing

Medium temperature

0.48 × TDA + 1.95

VCT.RC.L

Vertical transparent door

Remote condensing

Low temperature

1.03 × TDA + 2.61

SOC.RC.M

Service over counter

Remote condensing

Medium temperature

0.62 × TDA + 0.11

VOP.SC.M

Vertical open

Self-contained

Medium temperature

2.34 × TDA + 4.71

SVO.SC.M

Semivertical open

Self-contained

Medium temperature

2.23 × TDA + 4.59

HZO.SC.M

Horizontal open

Self-contained

Medium temperature

1.14 × TDA + 5.55

HZO.SC.L

Horizontal open

Self-contained

Low temperature

2.63 × TDA + 7.08

VCT.SC.I

Vertical transparent door

Self-contained

Ice Cream

1.63 × TDA + 3.29

VCS.SC.I

Vertical solid door

Self-contained

Ice Cream

0.55 × V + 0.88

HCT.SC.I

Horizontal transparent door

Self-contained

Ice Cream

1.33 × TDA + 0.43

SVO.RC.L

Semivertical open

Remote condensing

Low temperature

2.84 × TDA + 6.85

VOP.RC.I

Vertical open

Remote condensing

Ice Cream

3.6 × TDA + 8.7

SVO.RC.I

Semivertical open

Remote condensing

Ice Cream

3.6 × TDA + 8.7

HZO.RC.I

Horizontal open

Remote condensing

Ice Cream

0.87 × TDA + 8.74

VCT.RC.I

Vertical transparent door

Remote condensing

Ice Cream

1.2 × TDA + 3.05

HCT.RC.M

Horizontal transparent door

Remote condensing

Medium temperature

0.39 × TDA + 0.13

HCT.RC.L

Horizontal transparent door

Remote condensing

Low temperature

0.81 × TDA + 0.26

HCT.RC.I

Horizontal transparent door

Remote condensing

Ice Cream

0.95 × TDA + 0.31

VCS.RC.M

Vertical solid door

Remote condensing

Medium temperature

0.16 × V + 0.26

VCS.RC.L

Vertical solid door

Remote condensing

Low temperature

0.33 × V + 0.54

AHRI 1200

VCS.RC.I

Vertical solid door

Remote condensing

Ice Cream

0.39 × V + 0.63

HCS.RC.M

Horizontal solid door

Remote condensing

Medium temperature

0.16 × V + 0.26

HCS.RC.L

Horizontal solid door

Remote condensing

Low temperature

0.33 × V + 0.54

HCS.RC.I

Horizontal solid door

Remote condensing

Ice Cream

0.39 × V + 0.63

SOC.RC.L

Service over counter

Remote condensing

Low temperature

1.3 × TDA + 0.22

SOC.RC.I

Service over counter

Remote condensing

Ice Cream

1.52 × TDA + 0.26

VOP.SC.L

Vertical open

Self-contained

Low temperature

5.87 × TDA + 11.82

VOP.SC.I

Vertical open

Self-contained

Ice Cream

7.45 × TDA + 15.02

SVO.SC.L

Semivertical open

Self-contained

Low temperature

5.59 × TDA + 11.51

SVO.SC.I

Semivertical open

Self-contained

Ice Cream

7.11 × TDA + 14.63

HZO.SC.I

Horizontal open

Self-contained

Ice Cream

3.35 × TDA + 9.0

SOC.SC.I

Service over counter

Self-contained

Ice Cream

2.13 × TDA + 0.36

HCS.SC.I

Horizontal solid door

Self-contained

Ice Cream

0.55 × V + 0.88

(a)   Equipment class designations consist of a combination (in sequential order separated by periods [AAA].[BB].[C]) of the following:

(AAA) An equipment family code (VOP = vertical open, SVO = semivertical open, HZO = horizontal open, VCT = vertical transparent doors, VCS = vertical solid doors, HCT = horizontal transparent doors, HCS = horizontal solid doors, and SOC = service over counter); (BB) An operating mode code (RC = remote condensing and SC = self-contained); and (C) A rating temperature code (M = medium temperature [38°F], L = low temperature [0°F], or I = ice cream temperature [15°F]). For example, “VOP.RC.M” refers to the “vertical open, remote condensing.”

(b)  V is the volume of the case (ft3) as measured in AHRI Standard 1200, Appendix C.

(c)   TDA is the total display area of the case (ft2) as measured in AHRI Standard 1200, Appendix D.

The PRM does not include standard levels of performance for walk-in refrigerators and freezers. COMNET (COMNET 2017) default values for these are given in Table 17. These values are expressed in W/ft² of refrigerator or freezer area. This power is assumed to occur continuously. Some walk-ins have glass display doors on one side so that products can be loaded from the back. Glass display doors increase the power requirements of walk-ins. Additional power is added when glass display doors are present. The total power for walk-in refrigerators and freezers is given in Equation (4).

 

(4)

 

Where:

PWalk-in  =   The estimated power density for the walk-in refrigerator or freezer in (W)

Axxx      =   The area of the walk-in refrigerator or freezer (ft²)

Nxxx      =   The number of glass display doors (unitless)

PDxxx    =   The power density of the walk-in refrigerator or freezer taken from Table 17 (W/ft²)

Dxxx      =   The power associated with a glass display door for a walk-in refrigerator or freezer (W/door)

xxx subscript indicating a walk-in freezer (Frz) or refrigerator (Ref)

Table 17. Default Power for Walk-In Refrigerators and Freezers (W/ft²)

Floor Area

Refrigerator

Freezer

100 ft² or less

8.0

16.0

101 ft² to 250 ft²

6.0

12.0

251 ft² to 450 ft²

5.0

9.5

451 ft² to 650 ft²

4.5

8.0

651 ft² to 800 ft²

4.0

7.0

801 ft² to 1,000 ft²

3.5

6.5

More than 1,000 ft²

3.0

6.0

Additional Power for Each Glass Display Door

105

325

Source: These values are determined using the procedures of the Heatcraft Engineering Manual, Commercial Refrigeration Cooling and Freezing Load Calculations and Reference Guide, August 2006. The energy efficiency ratio (EER) is assumed to be 12.39 for refrigerators and 6.33 for freezers. The specific efficiency is assumed to be 70 for refrigerators and 50 for freezers. Operating temperature is assumed to be 35°F for refrigerators and -10°F for freezers.

 

Refrigeration Modeling Method

Applicability

All buildings that have commercial refrigeration for cold storage or display

Definition

The method used to estimate refrigeration energy and to model the thermal interaction with the space where casework is located. Three methods are included in this manual:

  • Modeling Defaults

COMNET defaults. With this method, the methodology described above can be used for modeling walk-in refrigerators and freezers. Schedules are assumed to be continuous operation.

  • Performance rating method. With this method, the energy modeler takes inventory of the refrigerated casework in the rated building and sums the rated energy use (typically in kWh/day). All refrigeration equipment is then assumed to operate continuously.
  • Explicit refrigeration model. With this method, all components of the refrigeration system are explicitly modeled in DOE-2.2R or another hourly simulation program with this capability. This method is not covered by this manual.
  • AHRI Rated Energy. Rated energy use in accordance with AHRI 1200.
  • 10 CFR 431 Rated Energy. Rated energy use in accordance with 10 CFR 431.

Units

List (see above)

Input Restrictions

When refrigeration equipment in the proposed design is rated in accordance with AHRI 1200 or 10 CFR 431, the rated energy use shall be modeled.

For all other refrigeration equipment shall be modeled using actual equipment capacities and efficiencies using the performance rating method. If actual equipment capacities and efficiencies are not known, COMNET defaults can be used.

Baseline Building

G3.2 New Construction/Major Alterations

If refrigeration equipment is listed in Table 15 and Table 16 of this manual, then the baseline building design shall be modeled according to Table 15 and Table 16. For refrigeration equipment not listed in either of these two tables, the baseline building shall be modeled to be the same as the proposed design.

G3.3 Minor Alterations

If refrigeration equipment is listed in Standard 90.1 2022 Tables 6.8.1-11, 18, 19, or 20, then the baseline building design shall be modeled according to these tables.

For refrigeration equipment not listed in these tables and where projects are modeling credit for exceeding the minimum requirements in 90.1-2022 Sections 6.4.5 and/or 6.5.11 projects must demonstrate savings by explicitly modeling refrigeration systems or by providing exceptional calculations that meet the requirements of 90.1-2022 Section G2.5 subject to AHJ approval.

Exception: refrigeration equipment should be modeled the same in the baseline and proposed if, based on the requirements of 90.1-2022 Section 6.1.4 and the scope of the alteration, 90.1-2022 Sections 6.4.1, 6.4.5, and 6.5.11 requirements are inapplicable.

 

Refrigeration Power

Applicability

All buildings or spaces that have commercial refrigeration for cold storage or display and do not use the explicit refrigeration model

Definition

Commercial refrigeration power is the average power for all commercial refrigeration equipment, assuming constant year-round operation. Equipment includes walk-in refrigerators and freezers, open refrigerated casework, and closed refrigerated casework. It does not include residential type refrigerators used in kitchenettes or refrigerated vending machines. These are covered under receptacle power.

Units

Kilowatts (kW) or W/ft2

Input Restrictions

With the performance rating method, refrigeration power is estimated by summing the kWh/day for all the refrigeration equipment in the space and dividing by 24 hours. The refrigeration power for walk-in refrigerators and freezers is added to this value.

Baseline Building

G3.2 New Construction/Major Alterations

When the performance rating method is used, refrigeration power for casework shall be determined from Table 15 and Table 16; the power for walk-in refrigerators and freezers shall be the same as the proposed design.

G3.3 Minor Alterations

If refrigeration equipment is listed in Standard 90.1 2022 Tables 6.8.1-11, 18, or 19, then refrigeration power for casework shall be determined from Standard 90.1 2022 Tables 6.8.1-11, 18, or 19; the power for walk-in refrigerators and freezers shall be the same as the proposed design except when adjusting for an efficiency improvement over the minimum required efficiency from Standard 90.1 2022 Table 6.8.1-20 and/or when claiming credit for exceeding the minimum requirements associated with 90.1-2022 Sections 6.4.5 and/or 6.5.11.

For refrigeration equipment not listed in Tables 6.8.1-11, 18, or 19 and where projects are modeling credit for exceeding the minimum requirements in 90.1-2022 Sections 6.4.5 and/or 6.5.11 projects must demonstrate savings by explicitly modeling refrigeration systems or by providing exceptional calculations that meet the requirements of 90.1-2022 Section G2.5 subject to AHJ approval.

Exception: refrigeration equipment should be modeled the same in the baseline and proposed if, based on the requirements of 90.1-2022 Section 6.1.4 and the scope of the alteration, 90.1-2022 Sections 6.4.1, 6.4.5, and 6.5.11 requirements are inapplicable.

G3.2 New Construction/Major Alterations and G3.3 Minor Alterations

Variations of the power requirements, schedules, or control sequences of the refrigeration equipment modeled in the baseline building from those in the proposed design shall be allowed by the rating authority based upon documentation that the refrigeration equipment installed in the proposed design represents a significant verifiable departure from documented conventional practice.

The burden of this documentation is to demonstrate that accepted conventional practice would result in Baseline Building refrigeration equipment different from that installed in the proposed design. Occupancy and occupancy schedules shall not be changed.

NOTE: Any variation between proposed and baseline refrigeration power should be reported for rating authority approval and inspection.

 

Remote Condenser Fraction

Applicability

All buildings that have commercial refrigeration for cold storage or display and use the DOE performance ratings methods

Definition

The fraction of condenser heat that is rejected to the outdoors. For self-contained refrigeration casework, this value will be zero. For remote condenser systems, this value is 1.0 and the heat gain fraction to the space through the condenser is zero. For combination systems, the value should be weighted according to refrigeration capacity.

For refrigeration with self-contained condensers and compressors, the heat that is removed from the space is equal to the heat that is rejected to the space, since the evaporator and condenser are both located in the same space. There may be some latent cooling associated with operation of the equipment, but this may be ignored with the DOE performance ratings methods. The operation of self-contained refrigeration units may be approximated by adding a continuously operating electric load to the space that is equal to the energy consumption of the refrigeration units. Self-contained refrigeration units add heat to the space that must be removed by the HVAC system. Hence, in the scenario where the compressor or compressor rack for the case is separate from the case itself but still within the conditioned zone of the display cases, the remote condenser fraction is zero and all the heat ends up in the zone.  For self contained cases, the heat added to the zone is calculated as shown below,

 

 

Where

kW    =   The power of the refrigeration system determined by using the DOE performance rating method (kW)

Qsensible-credit = The rate of heat removal from the space due to the continuous operation of the refrigeration system (Btu/h). A positive number means that heat is being removed from the space.  A negative number means heat is being added to the space.

 

When the condenser is remotely located, heat is removed from the space but rejected outdoors. In this case, the refrigeration equipment functions in a manner similar to a continuously running split system air conditioner. Some heat is added to the space for the evaporator fan, the anti-fog heaters, and other auxiliary energy uses, but refrigeration systems with remote condensers remove more heat from the space where they are located than they add. The HVAC system must compensate for this imbalance.

For remotely located condensers using the DOE performance rating method, the heat that is removed from the space, i.e. the Qsensible credit, is determined as follows:

 

Qsensible-credit = [Qrated * (1-LHRratio) * RTF – (Qrated * Elecratio)] * Lcase

 

Where

Qsensible-credit = The rate of heat removal from the space due to the continuous operation of the refrigeration system (Btu/h). A positive number means that heat is being removed from the space. 

Qrated = case gross rated total refrigeration cooling capacity per unit length (Btu/h)

LHRratio = latent heat ratio of the refrigerated case at rated conditions

RTF = runtime fraction of the refrigerated case

Elecratio = Ratio of cooling capacity required due to cooling load associated with use of lights, fans, anti-sweat heaters divided by Qrated. Depending on case design, not all electric power per unit length may contribute to cooling load.

Lcase = length of the case, ft

Use manufacturer data where available. If unavailable, use the defaults below. Note: these defaults are based on data from a single manuafcturer.

Type

Elecratio, Average Ratio of Elec Input to Total BTUH

LHRratio, Average Ratio of Latent Heat to Total BTUH

RTF, Average Calculated RTF (runtime fraction of the refrigerated case)

HZO-M

0.15

0.31

0.69

HZO-L

0.29

0.18

0.74

HZO-I

0.28

0.18

0.74

SOC-M

0.70

0.09

0.86

SOC-L

0.71

0.09

0.89

SOC-I

0.67

0.08

0.85

SVO-M

0.14

0.28

0.68

SVO-L

0.21

0.24

0.71

SVO-I

0.12

0.35

0.67

VCT-M

0.54

0.11

0.78

VCT-L

0.70

0.07

0.86

VCT-I

0.67

0.08

0.85

VOP-M

0.17

0.25

0.69

VOP-L

0.21

0.24

0.71

VOP-I

0.12

0.35

0.67

HCT-M

0.54

0.11

0.78

HCT-L

0.70

0.07

0.86

HCT-I

0.67

0.08

0.85

VCT-M

0.62

0.10

0.82

VCT-L

0.71

0.08

0.88

VCT-I

0.67

0.08

0.85

HCS-M

0.62

0.10

0.82

HCS-L

0.71

0.08

0.88

HCS-I

0.67

0.08

0.85

Units

Fraction

Input Restrictions

None

Baseline Building

Same as the proposed design

 

Refrigeration COP

Applicability

All buildings that have commercial refrigeration for cold storage or display and use the DOE performance ratings methods

Definition

The coefficient of performance (COP) of the refrigeration system. This is used only to determine the heat removed or added to the space, not to determine the refrigeration power or energy.

Units

Fraction

Input Restrictions

This value is prescribed to be 3.6 for refrigerators and 1.8 for freezers3F[1]

Baseline Building

Same as the proposed design

 

Refrigeration Schedule

Applicability

All buildings that have commercial refrigeration for cold storage or display

Definition

The schedule of operation for commercial refrigeration equipment. This is used to convert refrigeration power to energy use.

Units

Data structure: schedule, fractional

Input Restrictions

Continuous operation is prescribed

Baseline Building

Same as the proposed design